1944

Bill Floyd Bevens, Pitcher

Bob Ripper Collins, Catcher

Johnny Cooney, Outfield

Russ Derry, Outfield

Bill Drescher, Catcher

Walter Monk Dubiel, Pitcher

Mike Garbark, Catcher

Johnny Johnson, Pitcher

Al Lyons, Pitcher

Herschel Martin, Outfield

Mike Milosevich, Shortstop

Johnny Neun, Coach, Manager

Joe Page, Pitcher

Larry Rosenthal, Outfield

Emerson Steve Roser, Pitcher

Don Savage, Third Base

Paul Waner, Outfield, Hall of Fame

1945

Joe Buzas, Shortstop

Herb Crompton, Catcher

Al Gettel, Pitcher

Ken Holcombe, Pitcher

Dan Topping & Del Webb, Owners

Larry MacPhail, Owner, General Manager, Hall of Fame

1946

Larry Yogi Berra, Catcher, Outfield, Coach, Manager, Hall of Fame

Eddie Bockman, Third Base

Bobby Brown, Third Base

Frank Colman, Outfield

Karl Drews, Pitcher

Randy Gumpert, Pitcher, Coach

Frank Hiller, Pitcher

Herb Karpel, Pitcher

Hank Majeski, Outfield

Clarence Cuddles Marshall, Pitcher

Gus Niarhos, Catcher

Vic Raschi, Pitcher

Steve Souchouk, First Base

Jake Wade, Pitcher

Bill Wight, Pitcher