1918

Zinn Beck, Utility

Walter Bernhardt, Pitcher

Ping Bodie (Francesco Pezzolo), Outfield

Alex Ferguson, Pitcher

Joseph Happy Finneran, Pitcher

Art Fletcher, Coach, Manager

Jack Fournier, First Base

James Truck Hannah, Catcher

Miller Huggins, Manager, Hall of Fame

John Hummel, Outfield

Robert Ham Hyatt, Outfield

Paddy O'Connor, Catcher, Coach

Charlie O'Leary, Coach

Del Pratt, Second Base

Hank Robinson, Pitcher

Roy Sanders, Pitcher

1919

Frank Gleich, Outfield

George Halas, Outfield, Football Hall of Fame

Fred Bootnose Hofmann, Catcher

Frank Kane, Pinch-Hitter

George Duffy Lewis, Outfield

Carl Mays, Pitcher

Luke Nelson, Pitcher

Francis Lefty O'Doul, Pitcher

Pete Schneider, Pitcher

Ernie Shore, Pitcher

Curt Walker, Pinch-Hitter

Al Wickland, Outfield