1915

Walt Alexander, Catcher

Ed Barney, Outfield

Charles Paddy Baumann, Second Base & Third Base

Neal Brady, Pitcher

Ensign Cottrell, Pitcher

Bill Donovan, Manager & Pitcher

Tim Hendryx, Outfield

Hugh High, Outfield

Ernie Krueger, Catcher

Gene Layden, Outfield

Cliff Markle, Pitcher

Elmer Miller, Outfield

George Mogridge, Pitcher

Wally Pipp, First Base

Allen Russell, Pitcher

Bob Shawkey, Pitcher, Manager

Andrew Skeeter Shelton, Outfield

Dan Tipple, Pitcher

Charles Dazzy Vance, Pitcher, Hall of Fame

Alfred Roxy Walters, Catcher

Col. Jacob Ruppert & Tillinghast 'Cap' Huston, Owners

1916

Frank Home Run Baker, Third Base, Hall of Fame

Jess Buckles, Pitcher

Mike Cantwell, Pitcher

Norman Nick Cullop, Pitcher

Joe Gedeon, Second Base

Arthur Solly Hofman, Outfield

Edward Slim Love, Pitcher

Lee Magee, Outfield

William Germany Schaefer, Outfield, Coach

Urban Shocker, Pitcher

1917

Howie Camp, Outfield

Jack Enright, Pitcher

Wilson Chick Fewster, Utility

Bill Lamar, Outfield

Armando Marsans, Outfield

Bob McGraw, Pitcher

Ed Monroe, Pitcher

Bill Piercy, Pitcher

Herold Muddy Ruel, Catcher

Walt Smallwood, Pitcher

Hank Thormahlen, Pitcher

Sam Vick, Outfield

Aaron Ward, Second Base & Third Base